Z-Wave vs Zigbee vs Wi-Fi: Which Is The Best Smart Home Option?
In essence, smart home technology is made up of smart technology systems and smart devices that work together for improved security, convenience, and comfort in homes and business establishments. Smart home technology has greatly evolved through the years – from connections through coaxial lines to bus and IP technology networking to a centralized intelligent control system.
Smart home technology encompasses lightning solutions, smart devices and home appliances, sensors and surveillance, and more. All of these work together through a common connection, such as Wi-Fi or mesh networks. This time, we’ll take a closer look at three of the most trusted smart home connection solutions – Z-Wave vs Zigbee vs Wi-Fi.
All About Z-Wave
What is Z Wave exactly and how does it measure up with the others? What are its advantages? Are there any drawbacks?
What Is Z-Wave?
Z-Wave is a mesh network that uses low-energy radio waves to let your smart home appliances and smart devices communicate. Z-Wave was initially developed by the Danish company Zensys as a cheaper and easier alternative to Zigbee. It is aimed at smart residential buildings as well as commercial ones. You will need a Z-Wave hub that will allow you to control your devices utilizing a keypad or wireless fob and even your smartphone.
The network is much more restrictive than Zigbee in that it only allows 4 hops between Z Wave devices. The Z-Wave network itself is limited to only 232 devices. While this might be rather restrictive to commercial smart buildings, it is more than sufficient for most residential smart buildings.
Security-wise, Z-Wave uses the same AES-128 standard as Zigbee. Z-Wave devices operate on the 800-900 MHz range which means you won’t get any interference.
Pros and Cons of Z-Wave
Like any other wireless communication protocol, Z-Wave has its strengths and weaknesses.
Pros
- Easy to implement and does not require rewiring and sophisticated cabling.
- It has a low interference rate since it operates around the 900 MHz bands of the electromagnetic spectrum (compared to the usual 2.4 GHz).
- Wider network coverage at around 100 meters or more.
- Due to its mesh networking, it can further expand the coverage since capable devices become signal repeaters.
- It is power efficient and ideal for small battery-operated smart devices. Z-Wave is a fundamentally lower power alternative to Wi-Fi but with a wider range than Bluetooth and Zigbee.
- All enabled devices are compatible and completely interoperable with one another.
Cons
- Primarily designed for low-latency of small packets of data hence it’s not suitable for streaming and large data transfers.
- It has a limited number of nodes at only 232; it also limits the allowable number of hubs into 4.
- While system deployment is relatively inexpensive, implementation costs can significantly increase when expanding the network coverage.
- Only supports tree topology which may lead to configuration and performance issues corresponding to an increased number of nodes.
All About Zigbee
What is Zigbee and how does it compare to other wireless communication protocols? Will the advantages of using it outweigh the disadvantages, if any?
What Is Zigbee?
Zigbee, being a mesh network, allows signals to easily hop from one Zigbee device through a central Zigbee hub. This means that there is no need for devices to individually connect to your Wi-Fi network. It makes use of the 802.15.4 IEEE standard which allows cost-effective, low-speed communication between devices.
Security-wise, Zigbee uses AES-128 encryption. Zigbee operates on 2.4 GHz with rapid transfers; you might however run into much interference. In the US, Zigbbe can also run on 915.15 MHz but with a significant dip in data transmission speed.
Zigbee is a robust network protocol that can technically cope with up to 65000 devices and unlimited hops between devices. It also allows communication between Zigbee devices for up to a 20-meter distance.
Pros and Cons of Zigbee
Here’s a list of the advantages and disadvantages of using Zigbee to help you have a clearer picture of what you can and cannot do with it.
Pros
- It provides a great alternative to Bluetooth, Wi-Fi technologies, and Z-Wave for building personal area networks.
- It is suitable for low-powered devices that do not require a lot of bandwidth (including battery-operated small smart devices, sensors, object tags, and more).
- Zigbee provides compatibility with devices from various manufacturers and backward compatibility with legacy Zigbee products.
- Operates as a mesh network making it suitable for setting up smart homes and smart buildings.
- It allows for expandable transmission range and better stability since individual nodes fundamentally act as wireless routers or repeaters.
- Supports up to 65000 nodes on a single network which makes it ideal for building with multiple levels and/or large floor area.
Cons
- Susceptible to channel noises or interference since it uses a 2.4 GHz band.
- Competes with dominant wireless communication technologies like Wi-Fi and Bluetooth. This limits the choices of users and making them incompatible with mainstream consumer electronic devices.
- There are some security risks like unauthorized access to and control of a node, mainly due to intentional interferences.
All About Smart Home Wi-Fi
Does smart home Wi-Fi allow the same connectivity and conveniences as other network connection protocols? How does it compare?
What Is Wi-Fi?
Wi-Fi is a 2.4 G.H wireless networking or network communication standard that’s been adapted to work with smart home devices. Wi-Fi is also a power-hungry technology which means that battery life on battery-operated devices is much shorter.
Unlike Zigbee and Z-Wave, Wi-Fi is not a mesh network. This means that devices must be within the direct range of the router to work. Moreover, smart devices don’t repeat signals, hence, you might need to invest in a high-quality router or router mesh system.
Pros and Cons of Wi-Fi
Just like Zigbee and Z-Wave, Wi-Fi also has its advantages and disadvantages.
Pros
- It is highly convenient since it allows users to access network resources from relatively any convenient location within their primary networking environment.
- Deployment is easy and low in cost.
- Easily and readily expandable.
Cons
- Has several security weaknesses.
- Range, while sufficient for normal-sized homes and establishments. Might be insufficient in a larger structure.
- Subject to a wide variety of interferences.
Which Is The Best Option?
Zigbee vs Z Wave vs Wi-Fi – so which is the best option? Well, the best option is what would best fit your needs. Do you need one for your home or for a multi-level building? What’s your budget range? How many devices will you be connecting? Each network communication protocol has its strengths, similarly, each one has its weaknesses. In the end, only you can decide which one works best for you. Simply go back to review the list of pros and cons for each protocol.
Related Article: Smart Technologies That Have Changed The Interior Design Industry
